Common wisdom and current pay scales suggest that the longer one teaches the more effective they become. However, there is substantial research to suggest that the relationship between experience and effectiveness is not so linear. Here (The Impact of Teacher Experience) is a link to a recent publication from the Urban Institute. In short, teachers, on average, make substantial gains in their first five years of teaching. After this point, however, gains are marginal, and there is some evidence to suggest that, on average, there can be points of decline. "This and other research shows that, on average, teachers with more than 20 years of experience are more effective than teachers with no experience, but are not much more effective than those with 5 years of experience" (Rice, 2010, p. 2). The brief does acknowledge the heterogenity across subjects and grade-levels and the complexity of differential attrition rates and teaching positions (e.g., high vs. low poverty schools). Nonetheless, the findings are noteworthy--experience does not always correlate to increases in student achievement!
Price suggests front-loading experience and pay in the first few years, adding incentives for on-going professional development, redistributing experienced teachers. Beyond these general suggestions, how can we help teachers continually better their practice? From a more controversial standpoint, how can we attract teachers who are more driven to improve their practice? From (my favorite) a person-environment fit perspective, how do we shape the profession so that it promotes growth and attracts growth-oriented people? As a school psychologist, I cannot help to wonder the relationships between teacher experience and students' relationship with teachers, or social-emotional well-being.
Inevitably, there will be some marked decline in marginal improvement, but to see actual declines in effectiveness is unsettling and a call to action. This is certainly an opportunity to move the profession forward, and let's not forget the ultimate benefactor-- Students!
Thursday, December 9, 2010
Sunday, December 5, 2010
Coping with Loss
At my clinical internship, I am working to understand the trauma and healing that occurs for African American males in Oakland. Much of their experience is very different from mine, and I work to circumvent those differences. The students' struggles, and the therapeutic struggle are trying endeavors, and everyone is working for incremental gains in self-determination, healing, well-being.
Because these victories can be small, I was elated to stumble upon this NPR blog (full disclosure: Tracy actually found the link). The men from Oakland in the video below recently experienced the death of a friend/half brother. Their expression of grief and coping is unique, real, and beautiful.
Because these victories can be small, I was elated to stumble upon this NPR blog (full disclosure: Tracy actually found the link). The men from Oakland in the video below recently experienced the death of a friend/half brother. Their expression of grief and coping is unique, real, and beautiful.
Friday, December 3, 2010
Divine Opinions
I recently had a political discussion with a friend. She acknowledged that, despite her moderate views, she believes on most social issues, "there just is no other side to it".
I remembered this conversation when I read news based on the pentagon report that 70% of service men and women polled about the Don't Ask Don't Tell (DADT) policy were in favor of allowing openly gay members in the military. Other headlines read,
and
Since when do the principles of democracy apply to civil rights issues? Why did we need 70% of service members to tell us, that, in their humble opinion, there would be no negative ramifications of the repeal?
Oliver Duggan deplored this paradox: Instead of celebrating the results of the poll, we should ensure the civil rights of a group are never again left to the opinion of the majority (think: any civil rights historical example).
This is what Gary Olsen was referring to in his 2007 article in the Chronicle of Higher Education, on the 'Apotheosis' of opinion. That is, exalting a subject to a divine level.
Here he laments,
"Apparently, nowadays an opinion will trump a fact, a reasoned argument, an empirically verified observation -- even a treatise by an eminent scholar. An opinion is the great equalizer, and everyone has one. It silences all arguments, squelches all dialogue: That's your opinion. End of discussion."
Further,
"...others are training themselves not to become critical thinkers, not to search for evidence or support of an assertion, and not to hold themselves or others accountable for the assertions they make."
We are perpetuating these notions when we leave critical policy decisions up to opinion. I can picture it now - the anti-DADT politicians in Washington, fingers crossed, waiting for the results of the poll, and thinking,
"Gee, I really hope the service members don't think our ideas are too dangerous for the military".
Saturday, November 6, 2010
Recent Education Documentaries
Two recent documentaries have stoked debates in education. I have viewed both, and I wanted to briefly comment on the films, their meta-messages, and their influence on education. Hopefully, this is helpful in the discourse, rather than incendiary for proponents or opponents.
Waiting for Superman
Website: www.waitingforsuperman.com
Trailer
I enjoyed this movie. Despite some seemingly misleading depictions or hyperbolic anecdotes, the movie was engaging, clean, and well-produced. The over-arching message is one the continued disparities and shortfalls in the public education system. In a cathartic manner, the movie exposes the lottery system that can dictate--for many students--who gets into a high-achieving charter school and who remains as their under-performing non-charter public school. Further, teacher unions are demonized and pilloried. The movie shows dramatically and redundantly how amazing charter schools can be, but it does not give equal time to the 80% of charter schools that function at or below the level of the average public school. I wish the movie had focused more on what exactly makes up an effective teacher and how to professionalize the practice, rather than bifurcating two types of schools. However, I really appreciated the point of relative accountability among professions.
Race to Nowhere
Website: www.racetonowhere.com/
Trailer
Cinematically, this was a weak film. Low budget or not, this film could have been sharper and more aesthetically engaging. As related to education, the meta-message is that a focus on standards, tests, and normative competition is having a negative influence on our students' social-emotional well-being and their ability to think critically. Moreover, the essence of childhood is lost when schedules are packed and expectations are raised too high. I felt like the move did not rely enough on the data, and I would have appreciated more cross-generational comparisons. Further, in my opinion, the efforts to generalize this problem across socioeconomic groups came up short and rang false. The best asset of the movie was its conclusion which provided concrete actions that various stakeholders can take.
Both movies have started a dialogue and brought attention to the education system, which I see as positives. Further, I enjoyed watching both movies, and I left the theaters with a sense of purpose and motivation. On the whole, I think both movies tended to be somewhat reductionistic (but this is to be expected, right?). To close, I think these films should help motivate us to seek out the true nature of the problems and evidence-based solutions, rather than replace the data and heterogeneity across the education system.
Watch them, and let me know what you think!
Waiting for Superman
Website: www.waitingforsuperman.com
Trailer
I enjoyed this movie. Despite some seemingly misleading depictions or hyperbolic anecdotes, the movie was engaging, clean, and well-produced. The over-arching message is one the continued disparities and shortfalls in the public education system. In a cathartic manner, the movie exposes the lottery system that can dictate--for many students--who gets into a high-achieving charter school and who remains as their under-performing non-charter public school. Further, teacher unions are demonized and pilloried. The movie shows dramatically and redundantly how amazing charter schools can be, but it does not give equal time to the 80% of charter schools that function at or below the level of the average public school. I wish the movie had focused more on what exactly makes up an effective teacher and how to professionalize the practice, rather than bifurcating two types of schools. However, I really appreciated the point of relative accountability among professions.
Race to Nowhere
Website: www.racetonowhere.com/
Trailer
Cinematically, this was a weak film. Low budget or not, this film could have been sharper and more aesthetically engaging. As related to education, the meta-message is that a focus on standards, tests, and normative competition is having a negative influence on our students' social-emotional well-being and their ability to think critically. Moreover, the essence of childhood is lost when schedules are packed and expectations are raised too high. I felt like the move did not rely enough on the data, and I would have appreciated more cross-generational comparisons. Further, in my opinion, the efforts to generalize this problem across socioeconomic groups came up short and rang false. The best asset of the movie was its conclusion which provided concrete actions that various stakeholders can take.
Both movies have started a dialogue and brought attention to the education system, which I see as positives. Further, I enjoyed watching both movies, and I left the theaters with a sense of purpose and motivation. On the whole, I think both movies tended to be somewhat reductionistic (but this is to be expected, right?). To close, I think these films should help motivate us to seek out the true nature of the problems and evidence-based solutions, rather than replace the data and heterogeneity across the education system.
Watch them, and let me know what you think!
Friday, October 15, 2010
Reliving my childhood... Two Glorious Nights with the Braves
Flashback to the 1990s. Growing up, I watched the Braves all the time. I have the 1995 newspapers from the playoffs, I cried in 1996 when the Yankees beat the Braves in 6 games, and my mom took me on a tour of Turner Field for my 12th birthday. Every year, the Braves made the playoffs, my teachers would show the games on TV at school, and I would always write letters to my favorite players (like Ron Gant, Fred McGriff, and Tom Glavine). In short, the Braves represent something nostalgic and formative for me.
Flash to 2010. I haven't seen the Braves play live since 2008. I keep up with the team through box scores and headlines, but this is a far cry from watching them nightly at the dinner table. This year, however, the Braves made the playoffs for the first time in five years. They clinched the Wild Card in the last game of the regular season, and serendipitously they faced off with the San Francisco Giants. The Braves were in the playoffs, and I was acting like a 10-year old... Suddenly, it was feeling more like the 1990s.
Seizing the opportunity, Tracy and I committed to go to both games in San Francisco. Luckily, Tracy's dad was able to help out with some great seats for the first game, and our friends, Dave and Adena, got us a deal on a couple seats for the second game. And the games did not disappoint! I saw an amazing performance by Giants' pitcher, Tim Lincecum; Bobby Cox's last ever ejection; a comeback Braves win in extra innings; and two beautiful nights at AT&T ballpark. I also got my fair share of heckling from Giants fans and two amazing dates with Tracy! A few pictures for the annals.
Since, the Braves lost to the Giants in four games. It matters not. Reliving my childhood for two days was priceless. Go 2011 Braves!
Flash to 2010. I haven't seen the Braves play live since 2008. I keep up with the team through box scores and headlines, but this is a far cry from watching them nightly at the dinner table. This year, however, the Braves made the playoffs for the first time in five years. They clinched the Wild Card in the last game of the regular season, and serendipitously they faced off with the San Francisco Giants. The Braves were in the playoffs, and I was acting like a 10-year old... Suddenly, it was feeling more like the 1990s.
Seizing the opportunity, Tracy and I committed to go to both games in San Francisco. Luckily, Tracy's dad was able to help out with some great seats for the first game, and our friends, Dave and Adena, got us a deal on a couple seats for the second game. And the games did not disappoint! I saw an amazing performance by Giants' pitcher, Tim Lincecum; Bobby Cox's last ever ejection; a comeback Braves win in extra innings; and two beautiful nights at AT&T ballpark. I also got my fair share of heckling from Giants fans and two amazing dates with Tracy! A few pictures for the annals.
![]() |
| Game 1: Lowe vs. Lincecum, a one-run thriller |
![]() |
| Me, Tracy, Adena, and Dave at Game 2 |
![]() |
| Two Lone Braves Fans at Game 2; An unforgettable comeback capped with a Braves Homerun hit into the Bay |
Since, the Braves lost to the Giants in four games. It matters not. Reliving my childhood for two days was priceless. Go 2011 Braves!
Wednesday, September 29, 2010
Stigma Matters
Mental health is gaining traction within insurance policies, and public opinion is slowly moving. However, certain sectors of society are continually plagued by the damning stigma of mental health. Specifically, the social norms of many male-dominated arenas have hindered the ability of some to seek care, preventative or reactive. I have written about the difficulties that our soldiers and veterans are confronted with mental health issues (July 10 Post). And the same could be said for professional athletes.
It appears that, Kenny McKinley, an NFL player, recently committed suicide after battling depressive symptoms. In a subsequent article, there is evidence that Kenny had shared his suicidal ideation before taking his life. "'He had made statements while playing dominoes shortly after the surgery that he should just kill himself,' an unnamed investigator reported, via the AP. 'No one believed he was serious,'" the article stated.
The knee-jerk reaction to incidences of mental health problems in these populations is that resources should be made available to players. The reality is, however, that resources are available. In fact, as a recent article indicates (Despite Resources, Players Reluctant to Seek Help), there are services offered to help players cope with various issues (e.g., financial, family). Within their player development program, free counseling sessions and trained staff people are made available on a regular basis. Further, "The NFL Players Association hands out cards with the number of a helpline. There are life skills classes, both mandatory and voluntary, taught on a regular basis."
So why aren't players getting help?
No one can be certain why Kenny did not seek help or if it would have prevented his suicide. Yet, it is likely that the stigma of mental illness prevents players like Kenny from utilizing psychological services. As participant of society, it is important to understand how we act, react, and participate in mental health prevention and remediation; these actions dictate the connotations and stereotypes of mental health, which may influence how welcome others feel in seeking help. This is especially true in masculine jobs.
It appears that, Kenny McKinley, an NFL player, recently committed suicide after battling depressive symptoms. In a subsequent article, there is evidence that Kenny had shared his suicidal ideation before taking his life. "'He had made statements while playing dominoes shortly after the surgery that he should just kill himself,' an unnamed investigator reported, via the AP. 'No one believed he was serious,'" the article stated.
The knee-jerk reaction to incidences of mental health problems in these populations is that resources should be made available to players. The reality is, however, that resources are available. In fact, as a recent article indicates (Despite Resources, Players Reluctant to Seek Help), there are services offered to help players cope with various issues (e.g., financial, family). Within their player development program, free counseling sessions and trained staff people are made available on a regular basis. Further, "The NFL Players Association hands out cards with the number of a helpline. There are life skills classes, both mandatory and voluntary, taught on a regular basis."
So why aren't players getting help?
No one can be certain why Kenny did not seek help or if it would have prevented his suicide. Yet, it is likely that the stigma of mental illness prevents players like Kenny from utilizing psychological services. As participant of society, it is important to understand how we act, react, and participate in mental health prevention and remediation; these actions dictate the connotations and stereotypes of mental health, which may influence how welcome others feel in seeking help. This is especially true in masculine jobs.
Thursday, September 23, 2010
Therapizing, Researching, and Covering Long Distances
[Disclaimer: I'm missing family, so I thought I'd blog to catch some of them up on my semester so far.]
As it turns out, when the semester begins, life gets crazy busy...
My weekdays have been filled with an internship as a therapist at a non-public school for students with emotional-behavioral difficulties. The challenges facing my clients are profound, transgenerational, and incredibly obdurate. My role is designed to be a therapist, but by necessity, I am adopting roles as teacher consultant, case manager, and (fill in the blank to whatever is needed at the moment). I'm making some strong professional relationships, and I am being challenged emotionally, professionally, and philosophically. With great challenge is coming great reward (I hope!). In my short time, I have quickly re-realized what an amazing dice-roll I received from God/cosmos (stability, support systems, privilege, etc.).
My weeknights have been filled with research on three different projects. First, I am continuing my own research on person-environment fit and student motivation. I am submitting my first solo piece for publication in the upcoming months! Second, I am working with a local charter school to conceptualize and measure gains in their first years. Tomorrow, I am presenting our findings to the teachers. My final project deals with high-schoolers' college knowledge (and I'm finding really interesting trends across SES and racial/ethnic groups!).
My weekends are consumed by endurance races. And by races, I mean finishing the distance in how ever long it takes me. This month, I ran my first two ultra-marathons (both 50kms), the latter being much faster and more enjoyable. Lou and Daniel provided some much-needed nutritional and preparation counsel, which benefited me greatly on the second go-around. Tracy has been supportive of these self-indulgent Saturdays. Tracy and I cycled to the summit of Mt. Tam two weekends ago, and this weekend, we are heading to Lake Tahoe for a Century. Although I have loved my trail runs, I am anxious to get into the saddle.
Never a dull moment.
As it turns out, when the semester begins, life gets crazy busy...
My weekdays have been filled with an internship as a therapist at a non-public school for students with emotional-behavioral difficulties. The challenges facing my clients are profound, transgenerational, and incredibly obdurate. My role is designed to be a therapist, but by necessity, I am adopting roles as teacher consultant, case manager, and (fill in the blank to whatever is needed at the moment). I'm making some strong professional relationships, and I am being challenged emotionally, professionally, and philosophically. With great challenge is coming great reward (I hope!). In my short time, I have quickly re-realized what an amazing dice-roll I received from God/cosmos (stability, support systems, privilege, etc.).
My weeknights have been filled with research on three different projects. First, I am continuing my own research on person-environment fit and student motivation. I am submitting my first solo piece for publication in the upcoming months! Second, I am working with a local charter school to conceptualize and measure gains in their first years. Tomorrow, I am presenting our findings to the teachers. My final project deals with high-schoolers' college knowledge (and I'm finding really interesting trends across SES and racial/ethnic groups!).
My weekends are consumed by endurance races. And by races, I mean finishing the distance in how ever long it takes me. This month, I ran my first two ultra-marathons (both 50kms), the latter being much faster and more enjoyable. Lou and Daniel provided some much-needed nutritional and preparation counsel, which benefited me greatly on the second go-around. Tracy has been supportive of these self-indulgent Saturdays. Tracy and I cycled to the summit of Mt. Tam two weekends ago, and this weekend, we are heading to Lake Tahoe for a Century. Although I have loved my trail runs, I am anxious to get into the saddle.
Never a dull moment.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


